Prison bosses welcome community service ruling for short sentences
The move has been welcomed by Department of Correctional Services regional commissioner Delekile Klaas.
Judge Thulare said a sentence of less than 24 months amounted to judicial warehousing of the accused, “who are generally poor and casualties of socio-economic conditions”.
“(The department) does nothing more than an act of storing them until they are released without benefiting in any way from such incarceration. (It) has become a convenient time-utility facility, storing people and releasing them according to their allocated times,” said Judge Thulare.
Klaas told members of the legal fraternity that correctional facilities around the Western Cape had their hands tied because they had to accept offenders referred by courts even though their centres were bursting at the seams.
“It would definitely be viewed as contempt of court if any correctional official or area commissioner had to turn back even a single offender due to overcrowding,” Klaas said.
According to the latest statistics, the Western Cape is one of the regions with a huge prisoner population.
In December 2016, the Western Cape High Court instructed the Department of Correctional Services to reduce overcrowding to below 150%.
Klaas said that should most judicial officials follow Judge Thulare’s approach, this would lead to some much-needed relief for most correctional facilities and save millions in tax-payers' money.
Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe expressed shock and disappointment at the sentencing of offenders to lengthy prison terms for petty crimes, adding that this factor alone contributed to overcrowding.
During a visit to the Goodwood Correctional Facility, Judge Hlophe was shocked to find that one inmate was serving six months for trespassing, while another had served two years for contempt of court.
At the end of the tour, Judge Hlophe announced that his team would visit various courts and engage some judicial officials on the concept of constitutional democracy and equal justice for all.
“These are our children, not animals. Any form of punishment should have the intent to rebuild and educate rather than completely destroy the suspect.
"We need to engage the courts and urge them not to be vindictive or seek to settle unknown scores.”
Another member of the delegation, Judge Siraj Desai, called upon district and regional magistrates to be compassionate and to apply their minds properly when sentencing offenders.
He added that any form of recklessness often placed the lives of ordinary South Africans at risk and often led to broken families, as most parents stood to lose their employment because they had incurred a criminal record.