logo
  • South Africa

    South Africa

    Nine-year-old boy raped at #Curro
    • 2019-02-20 08:55:22 AM
    • 24

    Nine-year-old boy raped at #Curro

    Arrested for murder of five people in five towns
    • 2019-02-19 06:24:40 AM
    • 13

    Arrested for murder of five people in five towns

    Zimbabwe company to donate laptops to underprivileged SA learners
    • 2019-02-19 07:32:52 AM
    • 13

    Zimbabwe company to donate laptops to underprivileged SA learners

    City tap water earthy flavour worries, Robertson chokes on 'poo' taste
    • 2019-02-20 06:32:01 AM
    • 13

    City tap water earthy flavour worries, Robertson chokes on 'poo' taste

  • World

    World

    Could homophobia and racism explain why it took so long to catch Canadian serial killer?
    • 2019-02-19 09:09:57 AM
    • 24

    Could homophobia and racism explain why it took so long to catch Canadian serial killer?

    Trump calls discussions on his removal 'treasonous'
    • 2019-02-18 08:41:02 PM
    • 8

    Trump calls discussions on his removal 'treasonous'

    Mongolian KFC outlets close after 40 hospitalised for food poisoning
    • 2019-02-19 12:58:38 PM
    • 8

    Mongolian KFC outlets close after 40 hospitalised for food poisoning

    French far-right weekly barred from Twitter over 'hate speech'
    • 2019-02-19 03:01:16 PM
    • 8

    French far-right weekly barred from Twitter over 'hate speech'

  • Business

    Business

    Saldanha Bay Industrial Development Zone concludes R3bn in investment deals
    • 2019-02-19 10:41:25 AM
    • 60

    Saldanha Bay Industrial Development Zone concludes R3bn in investment deals

    City Lodge expansion continues despite tourism dip
    • 2019-02-19 10:02:11 AM
    • 58

    City Lodge expansion continues despite tourism dip

    #Budget2019: Cosatu demands that Mboweni preserve jobs at ailing parastatals
    • 2019-02-19 04:35:50 PM
    • 45

    #Budget2019: Cosatu demands that Mboweni preserve jobs at ailing parastatals

    #Budget2019: Mboweni allocates R1.8 billion to implement land-reform projects over the next three years
    • 2019-02-20 02:43:24 PM
    • 35

    #Budget2019: Mboweni allocates R1.8 billion to implement land-reform projects over the next three years

  • Technology
  • Sport

    Sport

    The 19 experts in Caster Semenya's corner at CAS hearing
    • 2019-02-19 06:12:47 PM
    • 19

    The 19 experts in Caster Semenya's corner at CAS hearing

    Goss the hero as Wits survive penalty shoot-out against Black Leopards
    • 2019-02-18 09:16:47 PM
    • 12

    Goss the hero as Wits survive penalty shoot-out against Black Leopards

    Maties hold off Tuks to maintain unbeaten Varsity Cup record
    • 2019-02-18 10:30:40 PM
    • 10

    Maties hold off Tuks to maintain unbeaten Varsity Cup record

    Mamelodi Sundowns aware of the magnitude of Tuesday night's clash against Polokwane City
    • 2019-02-19 11:23:35 AM
    • 10

    Mamelodi Sundowns aware of the magnitude of Tuesday night's clash against Polokwane City

  • Entertainment

    Entertainment

    IN MEMES Patty's rendition of AKA's jealousy leaves Twitter in stitches
    • 2019-02-20 11:07:09 AM
    • 43

    IN MEMES Patty's rendition of AKA's jealousy leaves Twitter in stitches

    Bonang claps back hard over 'booty diss'
    • 2019-02-19 11:51:39 AM
    • 40

    Bonang claps back hard over 'booty diss'

    #RIPKarlLagerfeld: Iconic fashion designer Karl Lagerfeld dead at 85 - reports
    • 2019-02-19 02:11:20 PM
    • 29

    #RIPKarlLagerfeld: Iconic fashion designer Karl Lagerfeld dead at 85 - reports

    4 reasons to dive into the hit series 'Siren'
    • 2019-02-19 01:11:06 PM
    • 16

    4 reasons to dive into the hit series 'Siren'

  • Politics

    Politics

    #StateCaptureInquiry: Eskom board chairperson Jabu Mabuza to testify on Friday
    • 2019-02-20 12:22:16 PM
    • 24

    #StateCaptureInquiry: Eskom board chairperson Jabu Mabuza to testify on Friday

    #StateCaptureInquiry: Revelations of Bosasa's corrupt dealings last straw for Makhura
    • 2019-02-19 07:09:52 AM
    • 17

    #StateCaptureInquiry: Revelations of Bosasa's corrupt dealings last straw for Makhura

    Icasa boss's fate still in balance
    • 2019-02-19 09:32:48 AM
    • 11

    Icasa boss's fate still in balance

    #StateCaptureInquiry: Fuzile backs Gordhan, Nene as he concludes testimony
    • 2019-02-18 07:32:27 PM
    • 10

    #StateCaptureInquiry: Fuzile backs Gordhan, Nene as he concludes testimony

  • Opinion

    Opinion

    Dispelling myths surrounding the NHI
    • 2019-02-18 07:55:18 PM
    • 270

    Dispelling myths surrounding the NHI

    The life-changing Laureus Sports awards
    • 2019-02-20 01:14:54 PM
    • 11

    The life-changing Laureus Sports awards

    Ditching Eskom in favour of solar power is the patriotic thing to do
    • 2019-02-19 11:21:47 AM
    • 8

    Ditching Eskom in favour of solar power is the patriotic thing to do

    Is this the end of Bosasa?
    • 2019-02-19 11:34:19 AM
    • 6

    Is this the end of Bosasa?

  • Lifestyle

    Lifestyle

    A R3,000 bill for Valentine's Day burgers
    • 2019-02-19 11:31:49 AM
    • 160

    A R3,000 bill for Valentine's Day burgers

    Photographer earns his stripes with R1.7m SA record
    • 2019-02-20 08:22:15 AM
    • 63

    Photographer earns his stripes with R1.7m SA record

    Veronica Beard AW19 #NYFW hair trends
    • 2019-02-19 12:46:34 PM
    • 32

    Veronica Beard AW19 #NYFW hair trends

    KZN Tourism looks to position region as a top business tourism destination
    • 2019-02-19 05:02:34 PM
    • 26

    KZN Tourism looks to position region as a top business tourism destination

  • Video

    Video

    Home and Away 7041 18th February 2019
    • 2019-02-18 10:40:53 PM
    • 254

    Home and Away 7041 18th February 2019

    Watch DR Malinga Sing After Prophet Shepherd Bushiri Gives him A Microphone  In ECG
    • 2019-02-19 08:24:56 AM
    • 31

    Watch DR Malinga Sing After Prophet Shepherd Bushiri Gives him A Microphone In ECG

    Koffee With Karan Season 6 Epi 18 - Tiger Shroff , Ananya Pandey and Tara Sutaria
    • 2019-02-19 01:46:56 AM
    • 26

    Koffee With Karan Season 6 Epi 18 - Tiger Shroff , Ananya Pandey and Tara Sutaria

    Home and Away 18th February 2019 | Home and Away 18th February 2019 | Home and Away 18th February 2019 | Home and Away | Home and Away February 18th 2019 | Home and Away 18-02-2019 | Home and Away 18-2-2019 | Home and Away
    • 2019-02-18 07:49:26 PM
    • 16

    Home and Away 18th February 2019 | Home and Away 18th February 2019 | Home and Away 18th February 2019 | Home and Away | Home and Away February 18th 2019 | Home and Away 18-02-2019 | Home and Away 18-2-2019 | Home and Away

Opinion

http://www.safrica24.com/opinion/concerns-over-political-party-donor-bill-must-be-addressed/89513-news
Concerns over political party donor bill must be addressed
  • 2018-06-21 10:28:03 AM
  • 27

Concerns over political party donor bill must be addressed

The Political Party Funding Bill is before the National Council of Provinces (NCOP).

Criticism of the bill in its current form should be invited. If Parliament approves amendments to the bill, this should not be an excuse for prolonging its adoption, preventing it from being implementable before the elections next year.

Political parties will be expected to disclose donations above R100 000 directly paid by donors into their bank accounts, and report the donors’ names and the amount donated to the Electoral Commission of SA (IEC).

In the interest of trying to curb the influence of big, private donations on parties, the bill also prohibits certain sources of donations. Public-funding legislation is retained in the bill, but the bill establishes a “private fund” called the Multi-Party Democracy Fund (MPDF). Donors who wish to remain anonymous and prefer not to be affiliated to any one political party can donate to the MPDF instead of directly allocating money to a political party.

The IEC will distribute all donations amassed by the MPDF to all political parties represented in the National Assembly and provincial legislatures on a proportional and equitable basis.

Parliament is to be commended for quickly drafting this legislation in just under six months, and for the almost unanimous support for the bill expressed by political parties when it was passed in the National Assembly. It would be worrisome if there are hurdles that will prevent the bill from being effective before the elections.

In November last year, civil society made various suggestions for amendment to the ad hoc committee established by the National Assembly. Not all the suggested amendments were accepted by the committee, leaving the bill with various defects and loopholes. To draw attention to some of the issues, I will focus on three crucial ones.

Firstly, at odds with the motivation of the bill is a clause that allows donors who donate to the MPDF to keep their identity and the amount they donate a secret. The idea behind the MPDF is that a donor who doesn't want to be affiliated to a particular political party but wants to support multiparty democracy can donate to this fund instead of donating money directly to a party’s bank account.

The option for a donor to remain anonymous, however, goes against the spirit of the bill. This clause must be removed to allow the public the right to comprehensively monitor and evaluate relationships that political parties have with companies and wealthy individuals.

Secondly, if the bill aims to prevent influence and corruption through prohibiting certain sources of donations directly to political parties, it should prohibit companies that do business with the state from donating to political parties. The bill is an opportunity for Parliament to enhance public trust in the political system. If foreign governments were allowed to donate, and disclosure regulations made the public aware of this, there would be pressing concerns that an external influence is able to gain favour over the interest of the electorate. Similarly, if it was brought to the public’s attention that political parties receive donations from companies that do business with the state, there would be further concern as to whether companies are gaining undue influence from a political party.

Public trust in our political system needs to be strengthened, and all avenues to curb the influence of “big money” are important if Parliament is serious about engendering a healthy funding regime.

Thirdly, the bill sets the donation limit for a single donor at the ludicrously high amount of R15 million in any financial year. Exorbitantly high cash injections may be welcomed by political parties, despite the risk that such big donations could be a bargaining chip or means for a donor to control a party at the expense of the public’s interests. In a highly unequal society such as South Africa, this bill should protect the citizenry from wealthy elites’ interests, which are intent on diluting voters’ interests.

Another concern related to South Africa’s economic context is the disclosure threshold. Parties only have to report on donations above R100000, which might not be enough to fund an election campaign but it is still a significant amount of money - far beyond what the average South African earns. Especially at the local level, an amount of or below R100000 is enough for a property developer to twist the arm of a councillor to approve a construction plan that goes against the interests of a community.

Another scenario is that a donor could donate just below the threshold and avoid any scrutiny. A company may be able to donate an amount just under R100 000 and then donate under sub-entities of the company, avoiding any risk of disclosure and effectively donating more than R100 000.

In light of the identified defects and loopholes in the bill, one would think that it requires considerable changes. There are various other issues that civil society organisations have identified with this bill. In an ideal world, Parliament would seriously consider these amendments and push for this bill to be effective before the 2019 elections. However, one could argue that if these amendments are made and the bill is instituted before the elections, there would be at least some disclosure where before there was none.

* Grimwood is the party funding researcher at My Vote Counts NPC, a non-profit company founded to improve the accountability, transparency and inclusiveness of elections and politics in South Africa. It works to ensure the political and electoral systems are open, fair and accountable to the public, and that they remain relevant in the changing socio-political context.

** The views expressed here are not necessarily those of Independent Media.

The Star

  • Concerns over political party donor bill must be addressed
  • Concerns over political party donor bill must be addressed
  • Concerns over political party donor bill must be addressed

Related News

When push comes to shove, we are left powerless
  • 2019-02-23 11:20:28 AM

When push comes to shove, we are left powerless

Bolivia's Evo Morales speaks truth to power
  • 2019-02-22 06:21:16 PM

Bolivia's Evo Morales speaks truth to power

Morales speaks 'truth to power' on global UN stage
  • 2019-02-22 07:58:10 AM

Morales speaks 'truth to power' on global UN stage

#MotherLanguageDay: Children need more than good schools
  • 2019-02-21 12:18:44 PM

#MotherLanguageDay: Children need more than good schools

Mboweni, we need to look beyond the numbers
  • 2019-02-21 11:10:52 AM

Mboweni, we need to look beyond the numbers

BUDGET BRIEFING: Mboweni takes no prisoners and skips the BS
  • 2019-02-21 05:02:45 AM
  • 10

BUDGET BRIEFING: Mboweni takes no prisoners and skips the BS

What the #BudgetSpeech2019 means to you personally
  • 2019-02-21 09:32:26 AM
  • 8

What the #BudgetSpeech2019 means to you personally

It's not only the poor and uneducated that follow prophets like Bushiri
  • 2019-02-22 03:10:14 PM
  • 7

It's not only the poor and uneducated that follow prophets like Bushiri

What Shepherd Bushiri's followers teach us about the 'prosperity gospel'
  • 2019-02-22 06:04:07 PM
  • 7

What Shepherd Bushiri's followers teach us about the 'prosperity gospel'

Mzansi has 100 problems, but a cardiologist's cleavage shouldn't be one!
  • 2019-02-21 08:30:24 AM
  • 6

Mzansi has 100 problems, but a cardiologist's cleavage shouldn't be one!

Dispelling myths surrounding the NHI
  • 2019-02-18 07:55:18 PM
  • 270

Dispelling myths surrounding the NHI

The life-changing Laureus Sports awards
  • 2019-02-20 01:14:54 PM
  • 11

The life-changing Laureus Sports awards

Ditching Eskom in favour of solar power is the patriotic thing to do
  • 2019-02-19 11:21:47 AM
  • 8

Ditching Eskom in favour of solar power is the patriotic thing to do

Latest News

Now is the time to upskill youth in readiness for 4IR – Survé
Business
  • 2019-02-23 07:41:56 PM
  • 0

Now is the time to upskill youth in readiness for 4IR – Survé

Herschel Jantjies saves Stormers
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 07:38:37 PM
  • 0

Herschel Jantjies saves Stormers

West Indies' Cottrell salutes his army regiment after 5-wicket haul
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 07:35:07 PM
  • 2

West Indies' Cottrell salutes his army regiment after 5-wicket haul

Stormers and Fleck live to fight another day with last-gasp win over Lions
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 07:35:07 PM
  • 2

Stormers and Fleck live to fight another day with last-gasp win over Lions

Tito Mboweni delivers Budget Speech 2019
Video
  • 2019-02-23 07:10:14 PM
  • 1

Tito Mboweni delivers Budget Speech 2019

Hidden chemical 'bomb' found in devastation of Dhaka fire
World
  • 2019-02-23 07:03:17 PM
  • 0

Hidden chemical 'bomb' found in devastation of Dhaka fire

Cape Town City stun Maritzburg United in five-goal thriller
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 07:01:28 PM
  • 4

Cape Town City stun Maritzburg United in five-goal thriller

Ntamack fires France to win over Scotland
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 06:47:53 PM
  • 3

Ntamack fires France to win over Scotland

The General’s Daughter February 22 2019
Video
  • 2019-02-23 06:25:47 PM
  • 3

The General’s Daughter February 22 2019

Raja Sen's movie review of Total Dhamaal
Video
  • 2019-02-23 06:25:47 PM
  • 3

Raja Sen's movie review of Total Dhamaal

Alibaba Chief Executive rules out layoffs this year
Business
  • 2019-02-23 06:14:02 PM
  • 3

Alibaba Chief Executive rules out layoffs this year

Pochettino in ref rage as Spurs stunned by Burnley
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 06:07:47 PM
  • 3

Pochettino in ref rage as Spurs stunned by Burnley

Cape Town City emerge victorious in five-goal thriller with Maritzburg
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 06:07:47 PM
  • 4

Cape Town City emerge victorious in five-goal thriller with Maritzburg

Maimane: 'Use your vote to fire the govt that has been stealing from you'
Politics
  • 2019-02-23 06:02:05 PM
  • 0

Maimane: 'Use your vote to fire the govt that has been stealing from you'

BMW 8 Series 2019 in-depth review | carwow Reviews
Video
  • 2019-02-23 06:02:05 PM
  • 5

BMW 8 Series 2019 in-depth review | carwow Reviews

Chiefs held to a draw by Polokwane City
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 05:54:12 PM
  • 5

Chiefs held to a draw by Polokwane City

Sharks grind out win against Blues
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 05:47:27 PM
  • 4

Sharks grind out win against Blues

Kaizer Chiefs held to a draw in Polokwane
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 05:39:42 PM
  • 3

Kaizer Chiefs held to a draw in Polokwane

7 quotes from Maimane's election manifesto launch speech
Politics
  • 2019-02-23 05:35:02 PM
  • 5

7 quotes from Maimane's election manifesto launch speech

Rampant Sharks outmuscle Blues in Durban
Sport
  • 2019-02-23 05:32:17 PM
  • 5

Rampant Sharks outmuscle Blues in Durban

Follow

Popular

  • EC transport head suspended over Mthatha airport downgrade
    South Africa

    EC transport head suspended over Mthatha airport downgrade

  • Radical business forum targets 'Indian schools' in Durban
    Business

    Radical business forum targets 'Indian schools' in Durban

  • Newlands is more than just a sports stadium
    Lifestyle

    Newlands is more than just a sports stadium

  • Band Khirkiyan | Last Episode | Hum TV Drama | 22 February 2019
    Video

    Band Khirkiyan | Last Episode | Hum TV Drama | 22 February 2019

  • Task team to probe Potchefstroom psychiatric hospital following protest
    South Africa

    Task team to probe Potchefstroom psychiatric hospital following protest

  • Swedbank falls further on lingering money laundering worries
    Business

    Swedbank falls further on lingering money laundering worries

  • Tanzania's private sector to push for investment in processing industry
    Business

    Tanzania's private sector to push for investment in processing industry

  • Sports court to rule in Semenya case by March 26
    Sport

    Sports court to rule in Semenya case by March 26

  • Phehlukwayo stars with bat and ball to take Dolphins to victory over Cape Cobras
    Sport

    Phehlukwayo stars with bat and ball to take Dolphins to victory over Cape Cobras

  • Hetmeyr hundred sets up West Indies win to level England series
    Sport

    Hetmeyr hundred sets up West Indies win to level England series

  • Couple accused of starving their 13 kids plead guilty to torture, abuse
    World

    Couple accused of starving their 13 kids plead guilty to torture, abuse

  • Swede sentenced for royal jewels heist worth R98m
    World

    Swede sentenced for royal jewels heist worth R98m

  • 10 die, 6 hurt in illegal firecracker factory in north India
    World

    10 die, 6 hurt in illegal firecracker factory in north India

  • Sars still plagued by significant inefficiencies
    Business

    Sars still plagued by significant inefficiencies

  • Tesla rolls out Model 3 in China ahead of schedule in sales push
    Business

    Tesla rolls out Model 3 in China ahead of schedule in sales push

safrica24.com

safrica24.com © 2017 Contact Us